BROKEN SOCIAL SCENE"FORGIVENESS ROCK RECORD"
EARLY REVIEW - OUT 5/4
A note to all fans of Broken Social Scene: forget them. Forget everything you know about them. Forget their sound, forget their style. Because their 4th studio effort, "Forgiveness Rock Record", is NOT a Broken Social scene album. Well, technically it is. But if someone never told you it was them, you wouldn't believe it. Back in the beginning of the year when they announced their new creation, "Forgiveness Rock Record", they admitted that they were changing their sound quite a bit. I didn't think it'd change THIS much.
I got my hands on the record a few days ago, and the reason that it's taken me so long to write a review is just that. It's different. Broken Social Scene's second album, the brilliantly titled "You Forgot It In People", is my personal favorite album of all time, and BSS is one of my favorite musical groups. So when I first listened to FRR, I was...disappointed. Not because it wasn't a good record, but because it was not at all what I'd been waiting for for such a long time.
So I knew I had to think it over. I couldn't let myself sit down and write a biased review because that just wouldn't be fair. It wouldn't be fair because once I DID sit down to reevaluate, once I did listen to it unburdened with preconceptions of the band's past efforts, I realized something thrilling: "Forgiveness Rock Record" definitely rocks.
So, how is it different? Well, the title says it itself: this is a rock album. And sure, BSS has done some rocky stuff in the past, but most of their music is more categorized in experimental pop. With FRR, forget the frequent use of strings. Forget the haunting instrumental ballads. This is edgy, indie rock - at it's very best, too. Because BSS has done something interesting with this album: they had...fun.
The Breakdown:
The album opens with a track that all BSS fans are familiar with: the single "World Sick". This epic, at almost 7 minutes, fades in with a gentle riff and slowly builds up to its explosive chorus. This is as close to a classic Broken Social Scene anthem as you'll find on the whole album, and it's awesome. We then tread into unfamiliar territory with track 2: "Chase Scene". There couldn't be a better title; the song sounds like an old 70's techno theme for a cheesy spy TV show. This one was the hardest for me to get used to just because it was the first song I heard that sounded so unlike classic BSS. But after a few listens, the songs eery vibe and break-it-down chorus are totally rad. Track 3 is one of my favorites on the album: Texico Bitches, a seemingly light-hearted guitar riff undertones a brilliantly executed chorus, with grizzly base and leaping "woo!"s from the background singers. Tracks 4 and 5 are two more that may be familiar to BSS fans, as they were released as singles along with World Sick. Number 4, Forced to Love, starts with a sassy verse that beautifully leads into a melancholy chorus with noodling synth. Number 5, All to All, doesn't work quite as well; while Leslie Feist's guest vocals are great as usual, length kills the song, as it's almost five minutes, and other than an interesting bi-vocal chorus, the rest dies off in a repetitive synth twang. But don't worry, if you're getting bored with this last track, the best song on the album is here to cheer you up: track 6, Art House Director, is a fun, upbeat, all too short pop anthem complete with trumpets and an irresistible verse. Remember when I said they were having more fun with this album? Well this is the best example you'll find.
I'll go ahead and skip a bit so I can end on a good note: because Forgiveness Rock Record is lengthy at 14 songs long, it falls into the same trap of its predecessor, the band's self-titled. Tracks 7, 8, and 11 all fall into that category of "interesting to listen to, but...wouldn't these songs be better off as experimental bonuses on an EP?" Number 7, Highway Slipper Jam, starts off with a weird scat opening that I'd like to forget was ever recorded. What follows is a good enough little acoustic jam, but it's not something you'll return to a few months from now. Track 8, "Ungrateful Little Father", has a pretty great beat, and is definitely an interesting listen, but again, nobody's going to remember this song come the end of the year. Track 11, Sweetest Kill, has its heart in the right place, with its electric grunge pop, but it's very unfocused and feels way too overkill for this generally more upbeat feeling album.
Now back to the good stuff: track 9, Meet Me In the Basement, is the only instrumental track on the album, and it is absolutely fantastic. Separating itself from other mellow BSS instrumental pieces, Basement is definitely a rock song - just without words. And it proves that this can be a great combination. It's followed up by Sentimental X's, a much more chill song for this album than what's been displayed, but saves itself from the trap that Sweetest Kill falls into by remaining quick-pased and maintaining a jumpy feminine spirt through Feist's vocals once more and a twangy guitar riff. Track 12, Romance to the Grave's fast paced electric feel is gently coated with a chorus of female vocals, joined by over-recordings of the lead singer's voice. Track 13, Water In Hell, is one last upbeat, fun, rocky anthem, sounding straight out of an old Velvet Underground album, before leading into its finale, Me and My Hand. A perverted reference or not, I have no idea. But this quiet, short track about love is quietly coated with a guitar, some vocals, and a light siren in the background. A very nice, pretty, and even in a completely different record than normal, traditional outro.
Please, please, PLEASE do yourself a favor: if you feel like I did upon first listen, which I'm sure many of you BSS fans will, keep listening. By completely changing their sound, they group has taken a big risk, and one that will turn away previous fans and garner new ones. Yes, it is a little disappointing to not REALLY have a traditional new set of BSS classics. But don't be fooled. There is greatness here. Despite a few boring tracks, nothing here is bad, and the stuff that works will rock your socks off. As I said earlier, this is indie rock at its best. So forgive them for changing, because you know what? The new Broken Social scene may be different, but it rocks. And with an ironic title to go with it.
A-