Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Part 1, is a setup film. It is not much of a stand-alone story; everything that happens serves the main purpose of setting the stage for the real finale this summer. Hence the term setup film. But the seventh installment in the big screen adaptation series is also an extraordinarily beautiful film.
I have been a Harry Potter fan for most of my life, but I always treat things subjectively. As a fanboy, obviously this movie is a dream. But as a film critic, I still have a dear love for the movie, for several reasons.
First, let's get the bad stuff out of the way. While it is, as I said before, a beautiful film, it has many flaws. One of the flaws of a setup film is that it IS a setup film. It has very much a transitional purpose to it, which takes away from the overall magical, Harry Potter experience. This is not the ordinary Hogwarts adventure we're used to. In fact, Hogwarts is nowhere to be found in Deathly Hallows. The movie is just a series of buildups, culminating in one big cliffhanger that will make July 15th seem decades away.
For the extremely small percentage of you who don't know what's going on in Potter World, Harry, Ron, and Hermione have dropped out of school and are now on their own trying to find and destroy the remaining Horcruxes - pieces of Voldemort's soul they must get rid of in order to defeat him. The movie is 95% just the three of them, there are very few supporting characters in this installment, particularly in the middle act of the film, which lends itself to be both a strength and a weakness.
The weakness is that the middle act is very slow; they spend a lot of time camped out in the woods trying to figure out what they're doing next. With the presence of one Horcrux, it causes the characters to be easily anxious and angry, and this even leads to a conflict between the friends that ends with Ron leaving the group.
The strength is that as a result of this stationary isolation, the character development is stronger than we've ever seen it in a Potter film. There are some absolutely incredible scenes between the three kids who the world has literally watched grow up, and it leads Deathly Hallows to be the most moving and emotionally satisfying HP movie yet. We watch Harry and Hermione's relationship grow in Ron's absence, and the power of friendship feels stronger than ever. The best scene in the entire movie is one in which Harry comforts a saddened Hermione by dancing with her in their tent - a truly moving and heartwarming creation that was not in the book itself, but contains the spirit of its characters that Rowling would admire.
The movie has a lot going on, so it will definitely be a tough ride for those who aren't as fresh with the story material, although certain things are explained pretty blatantly, including an interesting animated sequence in which the deathly hallows are described.
The other major flaw of the film is the climax - it isn't bad, but it feels underwhelming in comparison to other more adventurous sequences in the movie. It's actually a very short climax, one that had room to be played out a little more suspenseful but chose to move along a bit too quickly.
These weaknesses, however, are definitely overshadowed by the greatness of the production. This is the most beautifully shot Potter yet, and may be the most beautifully shot movie of the year. The music, this time by Alexandre Desplat, definitely has a painful lack of the original HP themes, but if you can ignore that, the original score itself fits the movie perfectly. The editing strongly mirrors the excellence of these two factors as well.
As I said before, the film is also profoundly moving. These kids are now alone and without the safety net that Dumbledore and Hogwarts had always provided, and the movie perfectly depicts this dark and scary world. Tension is high and emotions are a mess, and it's fascinating to watch these kids, lost in the world, try and move around these factors.
It's incredible how excellent the action has gotten over the course of the series, and it would be an injustice not to include how good it is in this particular film. There is a breathtaking pursuit shortly after the movie begins that takes us through the sky and onto the highway during a battle between the Death Eaters and Potter and crew. Another fantastic sequence comes in the form of a mini-heist as the three leads must sneak into the ministry of magic. Another spectacular sequence takes place just before the climax as a group of "snatchers", agents out to find Harry, chase the three adolescents through the woods.
It is important to mention, as the three kids take up most of the movie by themselves, just how good they are. They've had an endearing compassion to them throughout the series, but here we see that post-Potter, Radcliffe, Watson, and Grint have very bright futures. I want to mention Emma Watson in particular - she's always done great as Hermione, but in Hallows, she's almost extraordinary. She can do more with a look on her face than most actresses in Hollywood can with a monologue, and she perfectly maintains a strong sense of female pride and assurance and childish fear and worry. Harry is emotionally driven and Ron is lost and confused, so there are many times where it's up to Hermione to save the day - and save the day she does. She's a wonder.
There is going to be much gripe over the film for its flaws - too slow, too un-Potter, too dark - but what people are forgetting is that this is only the first half of the epic finale. I almost feel like I'm cheating by judging this film by itself at all; it's part of something much bigger. Don't overestimate Part 1, there is more to come - this is merely a preview, a setup. And what a magical, thrilling, moving setup it is.
9.1 /10

























